Primary links

Conference or Journal publishing for computer science research

資訊科學系(computer science, CS)發表論文的慣例大都是在研討會之上,這一點和其它領域是有所不同,因此也造成研究成果評量上和其它領域上的不一致。研討會和期刊等級有優劣之分,而在CS的成果表現上研討會和期刊的論文發表何者為優何者為劣,是很難用兩分法來加以論斷。最新一期的CACM(Comm. of the ACM)雜誌,兩位資訊界的名校教授,Joseph Y. Halpern (Cornell) and David C. Parkers (Harvard)點出了這一項問題。實際上在本文的參考文獻中,有9篇的文章過去也陸續在CACM中出現過,而提出這些文章討論的作者也都是在CS學門中舉足輕重的角色,如Ken Birman (Cornell), Fred B. Schneider (Cornell), Jon Crowcroft (Cambridge), S. Keshav (Waterloo), Nick McKeown (Stanford), Lance Fortnow (Northwestern), Moshe Y. Vardi (ACM Editor-in-Chief, Rice), Dan S. Wallach (Rice).

0. Joseph Y. Halpern and David C. Parkes. Journals for Certification, Conferences for Rapid Dissemination
1. Birman, k. and Schneider, f.b. Program committee overload in systems. Commun. ACM 52, 5 (may 2009), 34–37.
2. Crowcroft, J., keshav, s. and mckeown, N. scaling the academic publication process to Internet scale. Commun. ACM 52, 1 (Jan. 2009), 27–30.
3. Fortnow, l. time for computer science to grow up. Commun. ACM 52, 8 (aug. 2009), 33–35.
4. van Noorden, r. a profusion of measures. Nature 465:864-866 (2010).
5. Vardi, m.y. conference vs. journals in computing research. Commun. ACM 52, 5 (may 2009).
6. Vardi, m.y. revisiting the publication culture in computing research. Commun. ACM 53, 3 (mar. 2010), 5.
7. Wallach, d. rebooting the cs publication process.
freedom to tinker, June 2010; http://www.freedomto-tinker.com/blog/dwallach/rebooting-cs-publicationpr....
8. Wing, J.m. breaking the cycle. Commun. ACM 52, (dec. 2009), 8–9

毓忠

附加檔案大小
p36-halpern.pdf1.18 MB
p34-birman.pdf2.18 MB
crowcroft.pdf2.15 MB
p33-fortnow.pdf724.28 KB
profusion.pdf793.56 KB
p5-vardi.pdf520.56 KB
p5-vardi (revisiting).pdf554.09 KB
reboot-2010-06-14.pdf185.25 KB
Breaking the Cycle _ blog@CACM _ Communications of the ACM.pdf39.88 KB

Powered by Drupal 5.5 and copyright © 新趨勢網路科技實驗室 ( Emerging Network Technology Laboratory ), Some Rights Reserved
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.